God created the sky - and truly He is its expander. For example, Zakir Naik says, It was Edwin Hubble who discovered that the universe is expanding. Then turned He to the heaven when it was smoke, and said unto it and unto the earth: Come b. Then he turned to the heaven when it was smoke. (Surah 41:11). Most of these claims serve only to prey upon the gullible. The Quran reveals an expanding universe before this was known. To better understand, the universe can be thought of as the surface of a balloon being blown up. As per Quran, the word heaven refer to what lies above the Earth. Muslims claim that Surah 51:47 of the Qur'an mentions that the universe is expanding. But his opinion about the linguistic issue doesn't seem to have support in other tafsirs, when the origin of is discussed. The Big Bang 2. As of now, it is a proved fact that the universe is expanding. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. People would compete for the best poetry. Scan this QR code to download the app now. They were not "wrong" as long as they were not misusing the Arabic words. As the Universe rapidly increased in size, light chemicals like hydrogen and helium began to form. Also, get the book "Why There is No God" for free. So his interpretation is we have constructed the heaven with strength. I've always wanted to see how an ex muslim debunks these. What positional accuracy (ie, arc seconds) is necessary to view Saturn, Uranus, beyond? The Universe expansion rate is actually increasing. Debunking: Quran 51:47 "And the heaven we constructed with strength, and indeed we are [it's] expander.". It says God created the earth, then he created the hills on the earth, and then it says he turned to the heavens when they were smoke. Islam Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for Muslims, experts in Islam, and those interested in learning more about Islam. It is also said: We are able (qdirn) with the meaning of ability (qah) and power (qudrah). astronomers Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson made a Noble Prize winning This points to evidence of dark energy. Scientific Miracles in the Quran Debunked - muslimseekers.com "And it is We who have constructed the heaven with might, and verily, it is We who are steadily expanding it. Whilst some of the commentary cited above may be stretched a long way to remotely suggest that the heaven is being expanded right now in the present and thereby made to appear to support the central element of the Big Bang model of expansion of space, the irb (grammatical structure) of the verse indicates that the correct meaning of the verse is We made the heaven to be vast whilst we were constructing it with power. The particle waw in wa inn lamsin is adverbial (liyyah) 53 which means that in the course of constructing the heaven, Allh (D) made it expansive and vast. Could you clarify whether it is possible to differentiate between the definitions of the word 'samaa' so that samaa = universe, and not samaa = sky, or the other way around? [2] The meaning of wa inn la-msin is explained as follows by the mufassirn. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. All rights reserved. Atheist Republic - 2443 Fillmore St #380-8406 San Francisco, CA 94115| Atheist Republic 2020 | Registered 501(c)(3). rev2023.4.21.43403. You may not be aware, but the iERA (Islamic Education and Research Association)in their latest dawah initiative: "The Man in the Red Underpants" (I kid you not)are spouting this "miracle". 1000 years before Muhammad, Aristotle described a lunar eclipse that makes this very clear. The Quran was a poem, delivered over 23 years. This is a wonderful work. Quraan, chapter Hud, verse 7. to Accept. it depends on the context. The only Which religions followers will go in Paradise, If there is God then why so much injustice around, Determinism and Freewill: Scientific and Religious Analysis, Quantum Field theory, we are all connected, A Brief Summary Of Events In Human History As Per Bible. Most of the elements found within the earth were formed by fusion within stars of the early universe. "He who begins by loving Christianity more than Truth, will proceed by loving his sect or church better than Christianity, and end in loving himself better than all.". Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. The fourth, made expansive (huge) what is between the heaven and earth, said by alZajj. Some translates the word samaa' to heaven, while others translate it to universe (see Muhammed Asad). . The only conclusion that could be derived from a universe where everything moves away from everything else is that the universe constantly 'expands'. Thanks and welcome!! Archived post. Why wasnt osmium, iridium or uranium mentioned? Knowing Creator. What does "up to" mean in "is first up to launch"? "The Qur'an knew about the universe expanding 1400 years ago - Reddit are used. The word ratq can be translated into entity sewn to The Quran on the Expanding Universe and the Big Bang Theory Expansion of the universe . The story of Exodus is mentioned in verses 51:38-40. This comment has been removed by the author. Will they then not believe? (Surah 21:30). Quran expanding universe scientific miracle debunked - YouTube "They will find there everything they did and your Lord will not wrong anyone at all." (Qur'an, 18:49) Allah has created everything, living or non-living, which has existed since the beginning of. - Quora Answer (1 of 18): Almost every scientific miracle of the Quran can be refuted using other parts of the Quran or Authentic Hadiths which contradict the claim. Thanks for contributing to knowledge development. What are your sources? The Quran describes iron as being sent down from the heavens before it was known that meteors containing iron fell to the earth from outer space. However with more and more data analyzed from our various space based telescopes. It is the same argument skeptics hear from Christians and proponents of Nostradamus. Instead, he added a term called the cosmological constant to his equations that would make his calculations consistent with a static universe. of science and technology at the time of the revelation of the Quran (and for Secondly, it makes no sense to suggest it means God is expanding the universe after the verse has just said God has built (past tense) the sky and since the universe was already expanding nine billion years before the sky was formed. Just open the Quran, pick a word or sentence and see if you can apply it to something in modern science. Hubbles Thanks for shedding light on that. The "miracle" of the Quran is that it does seem to match the observable facts, whether the reader lived 1400 years ago, or today. Secondly, it makes no sense to suggest it means God is expanding the universe after the verse has just said God has built (past tense) the sky and since the universe was already expanding nine billion years before the sky was formed. about the universe. Slipher, noticed that the galaxies were moving away from dense point, and that something triggered the explosion of this point that The Big Crunch and the Cyclic Universe.Just a FYI, if any of you hear a Muslim bring this up as another "SCIENTIFIC MIRACLE" of the Quran. Due to the popularity of the concept, it ought not to surprise us that a range of Muslim exponents has as usual attempted to create links between this modern concept and certain Qur'anic statements as claimed in Quran. Hubble showed this by the Doppler Effect as the light waves from distant galaxies shifted to red, while if the bodies approached each other the wavelengths would shorten turning to blue. And admit me by Your mercy into [the ranks of] Your righteous servants.". And of course if the Arabic meaning exists somewhere in traditional Arabic literature such as Jahili poems that might also be accepted. Reddit - Dive into anything (40:57). Does the Quran actually refer to the expansion of the universe? only possible explanation is that Prophet Muhammad had truly received divine Haunted Brea: Lost Souls Spotted on Carbon Canyon Road In @Kilise Very interesting - I see now why many older translations of this verse refer to the ability to expand,rather than the active participle (expander), which we have in modern translations. Have those who disbelieved not considered that the heavens existence was initially extremely hot, then remnants of this heat should be The Expansion of the Universe in the Quran - Islamweb Yet, astonishingly well before telescopes were even invented But more importantly, the Quran is clearly not talking about the atmosphere but about the heavens where the moon, sun, planets and stars are because it also says We have adorned the lower heaven with the beauty of the stars. (Surah 37:6) and also he made the moon a light in in their midst and made the sun as a lamp. (Surah 71:15-16). Just to clarify, I understand that Arabic words can mean multiple things - 'samaa' can be either "sky" or "heaven"- but is it possible to know for certain which of these meanings is meant in 51:47 (i.e without using a potential scientific interpretation)? thanks looks like a great channel,subscribed, Great channel, I'm enjoying watching the videos and looking forward to more, "They call it the American dream, because you have to be asleep to believe it." The work of Allah is n ot o ver even after the c reation of . Quran 37:6 " indeed, we have adorned the nearest heaven with an adornment of stars" According to this verse our universe is Press J to jump to the feed. the matter in the universe came into existence from one single extremely hot Quran On Big Bang Theory - Blogger About the science of tafsir and "scientifc proofs, theories, examples" based on the Qur'an. The blog section of Atheist Republic serves as a platform for bloggers to share their opinions. As another person explained "we are able to" is a very general statement, and it makes sense that they understood the passage this way considering that they could not observe the universe's expansion. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. This wont turn down the muslims. Most of the debate pertaining to this verse is centered on the word 'musioona', and whether it implies an expansion of space in the past, or a continuous & ongoing expansion. Quran Says Universe Is Expanding - The Last Dialogue This is blatant example of attributing lies to Allh. And alak said, We have sufficed you, its evidence is the wealthy (al-msi) according to his ability (2:236). It has to be stated that 'zero volume' is a theoretical expression used for descriptive purposes. Noahs flood is mentioned in 51:46. And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander. (part 1 of 4): The Core of Islam, The Benefits of Converting to Islam We can use other verses from the Quran to understand what meaning is intended here. But I will to keep it hidden, that every soul may be rewarded for that which it strives (to achieve)." This remnant heat is exactly what Penzias and Wilson found. In 1965, Let's start with a quote from qtafsir (a somehow summarized version of tafsir ibn Kathir): Allah reminds us of the creating of the higher and lower worlds, Why don't we use the 7805 for car phone chargers? It is also said: We are expansive in providing sustenance through rain. [Al-Baghaw]: Ibn Abbs said, Powerful, able (qdirn and also form him, Of vastness in providing sustenance to our creation. It is also said, Possessors of vastness.. It was recently discovered ants communicate by rubbing their bodies. Hubbles new findings placed the foundations for separate and form into the seven heavens and Earth. Surat Al-'Anby' 21:31 reads, And We placed within the earth firmly set mountains, lest it should shift with them, and We made therein [mountain] passes [as] roads that they might be guided. Some Muslims have actually used this verse to propose mountains keep the earth from wobbling. A microwave map of the leftover from the Big Bang that gave 3$ / month : $3.00 USD - monthly7$ / month : $7.00 USD - monthly15$ / month : $15.00 USD - monthly25$ / month : $25.00 USD - monthly50$ / month : $50.00 USD - monthly100$ / month : $100.00 USD - monthly. #1by debunkingislam Sep 19, 2010 9:52 pm, #6by debunkingislam Sep 20, 2010 4:33 pm, #8by bdcarlitosway Sep 20, 2010 4:40 pm, #10by debunkingislam Sep 20, 2010 4:48 pm, #11by debunkingislam Sep 20, 2010 4:51 pm, #17by Hajj Baba Mustafa Jan 10, 2013 11:09 pm, #19by Spearthrower Jan 11, 2013 10:10 am, #20by Just A Theory Jan 11, 2013 1:21 pm, Users viewing this topic: No registered users and 2 guests. See Tafsir Tabari, Razi, Zamakhshari, Qurtubi, Baydawi. Dua (Supplication) (part 2 of 4): Praise God in the way He heavens and the earth Able to create the likes of them? Yes; and He is the And the fifth, possessors of vastness (in ability) nothing that we desire (to do) is difficult, this was cited by al-Mwardi., [Ab al-asan al-Mward]: There are five sayings: The first, expanding sustenance through the rain, said by al-asan. every living thing? Received. This is evident in other passages as well. Read the full thing down below, it also debunks the big bang: http://www.aqidah.com/creed/assets/docs/big-bang-cosmology-quran.pdf. Reddit - Dive into anything It doesnt contain calculus equations or engineering instructions for rocket propulsion. The prefix / La in Arabic is for emphasizes and adds a sense of, to a great extent. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts Browse other questions tagged, Like any library, Islam Stack Exchange offers great information, but, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. (Courtesy: NASA). Perhaps that is why it seems Islam is so new to apologetics. One hardly needs to point out that the stars, sun and moon are nowhere near the Earths atmosphere. matches what is mentioned in the verse that the heaven and Earth (thus the Al-asan, We are capable and from him as well, We expand the provision by way of rain.. This is false. How to Convert to Islam and Become a Muslim, Angels (part 1 of 3): Created to worship and obey God, The Story of Adam (part 1 of 5): The First Man, The Story of Adam (part 2 of 5): The Creation of Eve and the Role of Satan, The Story of Adam (part 4 of 5): Life on Earth, The Miraculous Quran (part 1 of 11): My Path to Islam, Stephanie, Ex-Catholic, South Africa (part 6 of 6), Angels (part 2 of 3): God bestowed might and power upon the angels, Khadija Evans, Ex-Catholic, USA (part 2 of 2), Happiness in Islam (part 3 What Islamic scholars say after they critically examine the Quran, Hafs Quran is Unreliable & Untrustworthy - Qira'at Conundrum - Episode 14, Scientific Miracles in the Quran Debunked. (The Qur'an, 21:104). The modern translation of Surat Adh-Dhriyt 51:47 reads And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander. This is compared with the now known ongoing expansion of the universe. be expanding, just as Hubbles Law states. changing font size, and more. were moving away from us. The elements present in the early universe were mostly hydrogen and helium, with a bit of carbon and other elements. The Quran is clearly talking about the pre-Copernican view of the universe that regarded the earth as its center with the seven heavens containing the sun, moon, planets and stars around it. In fact Abdur Raheem Green, the author, regurgitates so many old miracle claims one wonders whether he actually believes any of it at all. He (B) made it expansive.. For example, Surah 33:46 says a lamp spreading light (Arabic muneeraa) and makes this very clear when it says about the sun spreading light. The universe had come about by the explosion of this single point with zero volume. Al-Qutab said, We are possessors of vastness (in generosity, richness) over our creation. And the meaning is approximate. Contact Prayer (Salah,Namaz) Not In Quran? And the fifth, possessors of vastness (in ability) nothing that we desire (to do) is difficult., [Al-Thalib]: Meaning, in constructing the heaven, meaning, we have made it expansive (huge), it was said by Ibn Zayd.. yeah, i'm glad to be on this website. Cool channel. with speeds proportional to their distance from earth (Hubble's Law). In fact, Muslims are discovering new ones all the time. These features are based on cookies and will work correctly only when you use the same computer. There is absolutely nothing in this verse that suggests anything else. The earth is an oblate spheroid. Each of them seemed just as empty as any other religion. This discovery had an electrifying effect in the world of science, because according to the recognized rules of physics, the spectra of light beams traveling towards the point of observation tend towards violet while the spectra of the light beams moving away from the point of observation tend towards red. [Ibn al-Jawz]: There are five sayings: The first, expanding sustenance through the rain, said by al-asan. The sources are well quoted in the answer. In fact, it appears to repeat not only the accuracies of Greek ideas but their inaccuracies also. Why some verses of Quran refer to God as a plural entity? The Quran also contains several verses which are simply scientifically incorrect, but are used to prey upon the gullible and uneducated. Present Land Use. the invention of the first telescope, at a time when there was primitive knowledge This account follows the four stages described by Galen, writing around 500 years before Muhammad, and includes his belief that bones were formed before the flesh. Why register? explanation for this observation was that the universe had to be expanding. noor means light and is used many times to refer to God himself and so obviously cannot mean reflected light. One Hundred Above-board Questions about God, Why There Is No God: Quick Responses to 10 Common Theist Arguments. Allah constructed it. (http://bjp.org.cn/apod/glossary.htm). The very reason food is sealed is to keep information out. However, alaq has a deeper meaning, and it's root is actually "that which clings" and it is this meaning which people take today, since it matches the reality of our observations. His command is only when He intends a thing that He says to There is no evidence ancient Israel was founded by ex Egyptian slaves fighting their way out of Egypt with miracles. This is more so considering that, like the Earth, but were also moving away from one another. universe happened to be expanding in every direction, in the same way a balloon translated into We unstitched We clove them asunder We separated or We have opened them. in science, is considered remarkable. astronomy - Did the Qur'an predict an expanding universe 1300 years It is he who has let free the two bodies of flowing water one palatable and sweet, and the other salt and bitter yet he has made a barrier between them, a partition that it is forbidden to pass. (Surah 25:53) There are other meanings that could be applied to this.
quran expanding universe debunked
29
May